Reservation benefits only for Delhi student, not for those who passed class 12 from NCR school: HC

Reservation benefits only for Delhi student, not for those who passed class 12 from NCR school: HC

Last Updated Sep - 02 - 2022, 11:54 AM | Source : The FELA | PTI | Visitors : 62

Students who passed 12th exams from NCR school can’t avail benefits of reservation for Delhi candidate in college admissions in Delhi.

New Delhi: Delhi student who passed his class 12 examination from an NCR school cannot avail benefit of reservation available to a Delhi candidate in admissions in a college of the national capital, the Delhi High Court has held. Justice Sanjeev Narula said that the language of the relevant provision of the Delhi Diploma Level Technical Education Institutions (Prohibition of Capitation Fee, Regulation of Admission, Fixation of Non-Exploitive Fee and Other Measures to Ensure Equity and Excellence) Act is clear and unambiguous and the term Delhi candidate means a candidate who has appeared for or passed the qualifying examination from a recognized school or institution which is in Delhi.

READ | JEE Advanced 2022 Answer Key to release tomorrow, here's direct link & how to download

The court passed the order on a petition by a student who completed class 12 education from a school in Gurugram while being a resident here and now sought the benefit of reservation for college admission here. The petitioner said that till class 5, he studied in the Delhi “branch" of the school and the Act ought not to disqualify students who are residents of Delhi and have passed the qualifying examination i.e. class 12 examination from a school located outside of the city but within NCR, from availing the benefit of reservation available for the locals.

Dismissing the petition, the court said the determining factor to avail the benefit is the geographic location of the school providing the pass certificate of the qualifying examination, as opposed to the domicile of the student. The court noted that the school in Gurugram was not just a branch of the petitioner’s earlier school in Delhi but a separate school recognized by the government of Haryana and fell under the ambit of the Haryana education department.

The determining factor to avail the benefit is the geographic location of the school providing the pass certificate of the qualifying examination, as opposed to the domicile of the student. Although the term ‘Delhi student’ which appears in Section 12(1)(b) of the 2007 Act is not specifically defined or equated to the term ‘Delhi candidate’; however, the reference to ‘Delhi student’, in the said provision, in the context of the instant statute, can have only one meaning, i.e. ‘Delhi candidate’, said the court in an order released on Wednesday. The language of Section 3(g) of the 2007 Act is clear and unambiguous.

READ | New turn in education system of India: Pradhan in G-20 education ministers' meeting

The term ‘Delhi candidate’ means a candidate who has appeared for or passed the qualifying examination from a recognized school or institution which is situated in Delhi. In the present case, Petitioner No. 2 (student) has cleared his qualifying examination (i.e. class 12 examinations) at TSRS Gurugram and would not be eligible as a ‘Delhi candidate’, and thus, cannot avail the benefit under Section 12(1)(b) of the 2007 Act, the court added.

The court further said that once the petitioner gave up the challenge to the legality of the provisions of the Act, its validity has to be presumed and there can then be no scope to read down the provision or restrict its applicability in order to extend the benefit of reservations as a matter of interpretation of the statute.

Share :